Our Favourite Fireplace Surround Ideas

A fireplace is more than just a heat source – it’s the soul of a room. But if your fireplace surround is stuck in a bygone era, it’s probably time for a refresh! The good news? Designing and building your own fireplace surround can be a fun, creative, and rewarding project for anyone looking to make a statement. 

So, how do you turn your outdated fireplace into a Pinterest-worthy showstopper? Here at Heat Savers, our great selection of fireplace inserts is the perfect place to start! Let’s walk through some fireplace surround ideas to bring the wow factor back to your hearth. Plus, we’ll showcase some of our favourite fireplaces and inserts that you can incorporate into your design. 

Ready to light the fires of creativity? Let’s get started!

A modern living room features a decorative fireplace with glowing logs, surrounded by shelves with vases and decor, and a stone coffee table with a fur-covered chair nearby.

Find Your Fireplace Vibe

The first step to any great DIY project is envisioning what you want, and your fireplace surround should be a reflection of your room’s overall style. Whether you lean toward minimalist chic or rustic charm, the fireplace surround can make or break your space’s aesthetic.

Here are a few style vibes to get you started:

Modern Minimalist: Picture clean lines, neutral tones, and materials like tile or concrete that exude sleekness. It’s all about simplicity with a dash of elegance.

Rustic Charm: Think natural stone or wood surrounds that give off those cozy, cabin-in-the-woods vibes. Pair it with a Matrix 1900 Wood Insert; you’ve got the perfect mix of warmth and style without the hassle of chopping firewood.

Timeless Elegance: Are you drawn to the charm of intricate mantels, marble accents, and elegant detailing? This style is ideal for homes with a refined, traditional aesthetic. The Matrix 2700 Wood Insert is a fantastic choice for blending classic design with cutting-edge technology in traditional fireplace setups.

Eclectic and Bold: Want something a little different? Mix materials, play with colours, and embrace patterns. A fireplace surround is your canvas, so let your creativity run wild!

Materials Matter: Get Creative with Your Surround

Now comes the fun part – choosing your materials! Your fireplace surround is an opportunity to make a statement, and the material you choose can dramatically impact the look and feel of your space. Let’s dive into some of the top materials you can use for your DIY fireplace surround.

Fireplace Tile Surround

A fireplace tile surround offers endless design possibilities, whether you want something sleek and subtle or bold and artistic.

Ceramic Tiles: These are a tried-and-true option for a reason. Ceramic tiles can handle high heat, come in a gazillion colours and patterns, and are super easy to clean. Whether you want glossy subway tiles or hand-painted designs, ceramic tiles are perfect for both modern and traditional designs.

Porcelain Tiles: Need something a bit more durable? Porcelain is denser than ceramic and can mimic the look of natural stone or even wood. If you want the elegance of marble without the price tag or maintenance, porcelain’s got your back.

Glass Tiles: If you’re after something a bit more glam, glass tiles add a high-end, reflective sheen to your fireplace surround and are perfect for a modern makeover.

Living room with a stone fireplace, a burning fire, and surrounding furniture. Large windows with curtains on either side and a potted plant beside a shelf.

Stone or Brick Fireplace Surround

Nothing says “timeless” like stone or brick, and these materials are your best friend if you’re going for a natural, textured look.

Natural Stone: Marble, granite, or slate will give any fireplace a wow factor. Whether you choose polished marble for a chic vibe or rugged slate for a rustic feel, stone is an investment in style and durability.

Cultured Stone: Love the look of natural stone but not the price? Cultured stone (a man-made material designed to mimic real stone) gives you the aesthetic without breaking the bank. Plus, it’s lighter and easier to work with – hello, DIY dream!

Brick: If you’re going for a more classic look, a brick fireplace surround offers a homey, nostalgic charm. If red brick is too traditional for your taste, paint it white or black for a modern twist that still keeps that cozy texture.

A modern fireplace with a burning fire is set within a white mantel. Flanked by two gray sofas with patterned cushions, it creates a cozy living room ambiance.

Wood or MDF Surround

For those who want a warm, farmhouse vibe, wood or MDF (medium-density fibreboard) is a great choice for a DIY fireplace surround. Both materials are budget-friendly and customizable and add an instant feeling of coziness. 

Wood Surrounds: Natural wood adds warmth and character to your room. Stain it for a rich, traditional look or paint it for a pop of colour. Just be sure to keep wood a safe distance from the firebox, or shop our line of electric fireplace inserts for a safe alternative.

MDF Surrounds: If you’re looking for a more affordable option, MDF is versatile and easy to paint. It’s great for creating custom designs or built-in shelving around the fireplace. MDF is heat resistant up to 150°C, which makes it suitable for fireplace surrounds, though it should not be used in direct contact with flames.

Bonus: MDF can be shaped into intricate mouldings, giving you a high-end look on a budget.

Concrete Fireplace Surround

Craving a modern, industrial look? Concrete is your material. It’s sleek, durable, and can be custom-shaped to fit any design. Whether you want smooth, polished concrete or a more textured finish, this material works beautifully with both gas and electric fireplaces.

Mix and Match Materials

Why settle for just one material when you can mix and match? Combining different materials lets you get creative and design a truly unique fireplace surround. Imagine pairing sleek tiles with a rustic wood mantel or mixing stone and metal for a bold, industrial look. The possibilities are endless!

Measure Twice, Build Once

Once you’ve got your materials picked out, it’s time to measure and plan your build. No one likes re-doing work because of a mismeasurement, so be sure to double-check everything before cutting or installing. If you’re adding a new fireplace insert, make sure it fits within your existing fireplace opening. 

Here’s a basic rundown of how to get started with your DIY fireplace surround:

Prepare the Area: Clear out the old materials and clean the area. You’re about to give your fireplace a serious glow-up!

Frame the Surround: If you’re working with wood, MDF, or concrete, start by framing the surround with studs or 2x4s to support your structure.

Install Your Materials: Whether you’re working with fireplace tiles, stone, or wood, follow the manufacturer’s instructions for installation. Use heat-resistant adhesives, and take your time to get everything lined up just right.

Add Finishing Touches: Sand, paint, stain – whatever needs to be done to perfect your surround. If you’re adding a mantel, now’s the time to attach it and make sure it’s securely in place.

Ready to DIY Your Fireplace Surround?

Designing and building your own DIY fireplace surround is a fantastic way to refresh your home, flex your creative muscles, and add a personalized touch to your space. Whether you go with a fireplace tile surround, stone, or wood, you’ll love the sense of accomplishment that comes with creating something that’s uniquely yours. And don’t forget – Heat Savers Home Comfort in Victoria, BC, has the best fireplaces and inserts to bring your design dreams to life. Contact us today for a free estimate!